In your opinion, who won the Volladolid Debate?

Imagine you are a judge at the Volladolid Debate in Spain in the year 1550. Now remember, as a person living in Europe at that time, your worldview has been shaped by all the events of the day: the Spanish government′s brutal campaigns to unify Iberia and Christianize the peninsula. Also note that you personally have never been to the New World. In your opinion, who won the Volladolid Debate? Sepulveda or Las Casas? Who made the better argument, and why?

order now